Prediction Markets, Real Risks

Jeff Johnson and Craig Moreshead

Introduction

Prediction markets have evolved from niche forecasting tools into financial marketplaces attracting both retail and institutional investors. Platforms such as Polymarket and Kalshi offer contracts tied to elections, economic releases, interest-rate decisions, weather events, culture, sports, and a growing range of other real-world outcomes, including company-specific predictions such as quarterly earnings, acquisitions, and leadership changes. On October 13, 2026, the SEC approved a CBOE proposal to list options tied to corporate key performance indicators (KPIs), creating a new category of SEC-regulated, prediction-style securities products.

Volume has gone mainstream: nearly $2 billion traded on the recent midterm elections, more than $300 million wagered on Federal Reserve interest rate decisions, and more than $100 million in daily trading volume on the direction of Nvidia's stock price following its CEO's resignation. Because company-specific contracts may touch on subjects where advisory personnel have non-public information, unique market insights, or influential industry contacts, these wagers can trigger potential breaches of fiduciary duty and reveal gaps in insider trading policies, codes of ethics, and personal trading policies.

Background

Prediction markets are no longer easily categorized as online gambling, but their regulatory treatment is evolving. The SEC and CFTC continue to evaluate how existing regulation applies or whether new regulation is needed, and contracts tied to future events may fall under either securities or commodities regulation, depending on structure and venue. Two Advisers Act requirements are directly in play:

•      The code of ethics rule. Rule 204A-1 requires registered investment advisers to adopt and enforce written code of ethics addressing personal trading conflicts and fiduciary obligations, including reporting of personal trades and holdings. Most codes were drafted long before prediction markets became widely available and focus only on “securities” transactions.

•      The insider trading requirement. Section 204A requires advisers to establish, maintain, and enforce written policies and procedures reasonably designed to prevent the misuse of material, nonpublic information (MNPI) by the firm or any of its associated persons.

•      The definitional gap. Event contracts traded on CFTC-regulated exchanges may not fit neatly within traditional securities definitions, creating uncertainty regarding pre-clearance, restricted-list controls, holdings reporting, quarterly transaction reporting, and surveillance and monitoring.

The MNPI risk is concrete. A consultant who learns of a forthcoming government contract award, a pension adviser with advance knowledge of a major allocation decision, an employee serving on a private company board involved in a significant transaction, or a supervised person active in a political campaign may each possess information capable of influencing an event-contract outcome. Depending on how they are drafted, insider trading policies may be broad enough to capture prediction markets or may be limited to trading in “securities.”

What Advisers Need to Consider

1.    Find out whether your employees are trading in prediction markets. As part of an initial risk assessment, firms may consider conducting a survey to determine the extent of employee participation.

2.   Confirm whether your insider trading policy reaches event contracts. Insider trading policies should be reviewed to verify the extent to which they cover trading in event contracts.

3.   Revisit your code of ethics definitions. Firms should review definitions of reportable investments, securities, and personal trading activity to determine whether prediction market positions are covered.

4.   Update employee training. Prediction markets are still viewed as casual online betting. Training should explain that many of these products now trade within regulated financial frameworks and may create compliance obligations similar to those of traditional investment products.

Bottom Line

The rules are not yet settled, and it remains unclear whether and how Rule 204A-1 and Section 204A apply to prediction markets. The SEC and CFTC are still evaluating how existing regulations apply.

Prediction markets are becoming a more significant compliance consideration, and we expect that trend to continue as they evolve from fringe products into regulated financial instruments. They may create a new category of personal trading activity capable of exposing advisory firms to conflicts of interest, misuse of nonpublic information, and policy gaps that were never contemplated when compliance programs were established. Advisers should not wait for the SEC and CFTC to resolve these questions before acting. We recommend that firms assess employee participation now and confirm that their code of ethics and insider trading policies are adequately designed to address the new risks. We will continue monitoring developments and will flag any changes to your compliance program as they arise.

Next
Next

Record Deals, Rising Scrutiny